A Detailed Comparison of Backconnect and Classic Proxies

Backconnect and classic proxies have an important distinction: management layer. Understanding this difference will help you use both proxy types effectively.

A Detailed Comparison of Backconnect and Classic Proxies

The world of networking has a myriad of proxy types, all of which can be categorized in various ways:

  • Device type: mobile / desktop proxies.
  • General focus: datacenter / residential proxies.
  • Rotation: proxies that support rotation — and those that don’t.

To better capitalize on the given proxy type, you need to understand how it works — and if it has any alternatives. In this article, we’re going to look at backconnect proxies: namely, how they function and how they compare to classic (i.e. unmanaged) proxies.

We felt that this topic would benefit from a visual explanation, so we made a video:

Alternatively, you can read the text version below.

Article content

  1. Analyzing how they work
  2. Understanding rotation and pools
  3. Choosing the right tool for the job
  4. Additional benefits that backconnect proxies offer

Analyzing how they work

The essential difference lies in the way the proxy server is managed. Before we get to that, let’s step back and look at how the classic residential proxy works.

Client script is connected to the target server via a residential proxy

Let's say we want to crawl a website.

We have a crawling script on the left that sends a page request to the proxy server. In turn, the proxy forwards that page request to the website. The web server finds nothing unusual about the request, and serves the web page to the proxy. Completing the loop, the proxy forwards the page back to the client script.

Now, this scenario has no management layer. There is no extra layer of control between the client and the proxy. The script talks directly to the proxy, so we’ll call it “unmanaged.”

Understanding rotation and pools

There are two terms that we need to define to understand the topic better: rotation and pools. When we speak of backconnect proxies, we are really speaking of a software management layer that rotates requests from the clients out to many different proxies within a set, or “pool” of proxies.

🎯 Further reading: Exploring Rotating Proxies: Use Cases and Comparison with Static Proxies

A proxy pool is a collection of IP addresses

In our example, we’ll say the pool is only made up of residential proxies, but in theory, the pool could be a mix of residential, datacenter, or even mobile proxies.

🛫 Further reading: Residential Proxies: A Complete Guide to Using Them Effectively

🚁Further reading: What Are Datacenter Proxies and When You Should Use Them

🚀Further reading: All You Need to Know about Mobile Proxies: How They Work & How to Use Them

Let’s see what that would look like:

Client script is connected to the target server via a backconnect proxy

This starts out as the same use case: The client script requests a web page, but this time, it requests the page not from a single proxy, but from the entire proxy pool. That pool is managed by a software control layer that quickly considers a range of decision factors such as how many requests the last used proxy has made, and how many we want to limit it to.

The control layer decides either to use the same proxy again, or to use a fresh, different proxy with a different residential IP address. If the software decides to change IPs, we call that rotation.

Now, the selected proxy within our pool has its instructions to request a page from the website we are crawling. The web server sees nothing threatening or unusual about the request and serves the page. The same proxy in the pool forwards that page back to the client script.

That round trip shows how backconnect proxies work: They manage a pool of available proxies to rotate client requests among the members of the pool.

On the other hand, the classic residential proxy is unmanaged; the client script accesses a single proxy directly.

Choosing the right tool for the job

Backconnect proxies offer better performance, protection, and more

So, why would you want to use one or the other? Backconnect proxies offer higher data throughput, allowing you to get your jobs done faster. They offer better protection against rate limiting, which is where a web server decides your IP address has made a suspiciously high number of page requests within a fixed time frame.

However, backconnect proxies are going to come at a higher price than classic residential proxies because they consume more resources to offer better scalability.

What about classic proxies?

Classic proxies can help us in other scenarios

When might you prefer not to rotate proxies? A consumer trying to impersonate multiple different and credible profiles to access a single limited ecommerce offer would want to keep the same IP address for each profile.

In this scenario, we’re really talking about concert ticket purchases or sneaker copping. In these use cases, which are generally associated with individuals, using several classic proxies would make more sense than using a rotating proxy pool.

Additional benefits that backconnect proxies offer

Backconnect proxies can connect to multiple sources

To wrap up, let’s look at the other features and configurations backconnect proxies offer. Having more concurrent streams means capability to keep many connections alive at the same time, and the higher the number of concurrent streams, the more your backconnect package will cost.

More streams could come in handy when you are trying to crawl multiple websites at the same time. A great example of this kind of job might be a pricing aggregator website.

Backconnect proxies can also rotate IP addresses

Another feature backconnect proxies offer is the ability to skip over IP addresses that have for one reason or another been banned by certain sites. This is rare, but it happens, so auto-skipping banned IPs speeds up your crawl rate.

Conclusion

This will wrap up our discussion of the differences between classic and backconnect proxies. Each has its own place and value. Either provides security and anonymity. The choice often comes down to which is more desired for your hobby or business: stickiness or scalability.


comments powered by Disqus

Get In Touch

Have a question about Infatica? Get in touch with our experts to learn how we can help.